It seems like Short Sales are just accepted as part of the overall marketing mix now yet in practice they are a fairly recent phenomenon. Recent, that is, as far as the past 10 or more years go. Short Sales are not entirely new.
But why are there so many right now? To answer that, we have to look at some dubious lending practices that were being allowed, even encouraged, just a few years ago.
Most of us will recall that, in the late 1990s, those of us that live in the San Ramon Valley and surrounding areas were experiencing previously unheard of rates of increase in home values. An increase of ten percent per year was being taken for granted and it appeared that it would just keep going. There was a feeling of affluence and it seemed like everybody wanted to get in on the action.
Obviously, this was good news for lenders. When everybody wants to buy a home there is a lot of potential business about. Unfortunately, there was a problem. House prices were going through the roof, and even though interest rates were very low and buyers may have had 20% down payment many of them could not qualify for the monthly mortgage payments. That’s when the lenders got creative. How about if your monthly payment could be reduced by setting the interest rate even lower? And even better, suppose you didn’t have to make any repayments other than interest, that would get you into a position where you could buy the home you wanted. Now it was always clear that these loans were “temporary”. The technical term for them is ARMs or Adjustable Rate Mortgages. So a 5/1 ARM meant that the rate was set at a fixed amount for 5 years and then it would become an adjustable rate loan. A 3/1 was the same but fixed for 3 years. Many, as I mentioned before, were Interest Only. Even the major lenders were offering such loans. To qualify, you needed a good credit history, 5-10% down payment and sufficient documented income to show you could meet the initial monthly payments.
And then there was the first time buyer market. With home prices escalating, people who had not yet become home owners were becoming concerned that they never would be able to, unless they took immediate action. But many had no cash available, although they may have had a good credit history. Fortunately for them at the time, 100% financing was available, and 3/1 or 5/1 Interest Only ARMs were made available to the first-time buyers. Many of them still could not actually qualify for the mortgage they wanted so the practice of issuing “Stated Income” loans became commonplace, where the borrower did not have to show any documented proof of earnings. Stated Income loans were originally intended for borrowers who were self-employed and who typically had a 25% down payment. Using them as a device for people who could not otherwise qualify for a loan was a new development. Obviously these were higher risk loans and these were offered by the so called “sub-prime” lenders. Interest rates tended to be a little higher of course.
When a borrower raised the question of what happens after the initial 3 or 5 year period, the answer should have been that your loan payment goes up significantly, not least because you then have to start making Principal repayments. In practice, it was often suggested to the borrower that they had no need for concern because by the time 3 or 5 years had passed, their home would have increased significantly in value so they would have built up a lot of equity. They could then re-finance into whatever was the most attractive loan available at that point in time.
In reality, the whole scenario was a house of cards and in retrospect, it is easy to see that it was never a question of would it collapse so much as when would it collapse. When home prices started to fall we had a situation where hundreds of people owed more money on their homes than the home was worth. That is inevitable when you have 100% financing in a declining market. The situation is exacerbated by the fact that 3-year and 5-year ARMs are now re-setting and most of the affected homeowners have no hope of either re-financing or affording to make their increased loan payments. The majority are either burying their heads in the sand and waiting for the lender to Foreclose, or selling their home as a Short Sale. At least if they take the latter alternative, they have a chance to salvage their credit and they can hopefully qualify for a mortgage again in 2-3 years.